Article

· Industry News

The Value of a Framework: Using a Common Yardstick

Glen Yelton ·

October 26, 2026

Imagine sitting with your church’s endowment committee on a Thursday evening. A financial advisor has recommended two funds for the endowment to invest in. Both funds describe themselves as “biblically responsible.” Both have similar fees and performance. Both say they use exclusionary screens to avoid investing in companies that profit from activities counter to your church’s values. The committee’s decision seems simple, no real discernment required. The reality is, under the surface the two funds can be quite different.

For example, one of the funds might exclude any company with even one dollar of revenue from a given activity (a zero-tolerance screen). The other might only exclude firms where the activity accounts for more than 10% of total revenue. One fund might vote its proxies in line with the fund’s stated goals and convictions; the other might outsource proxy voting to a service with a standard voting policy.

Many times, this information is not visible to your committee. What you most often see are fees, returns, and comparative benchmark information – which is information that a secular investor would rely on when making such a decision.

The problem is not that Christian investment products differ. The problem is that investors often cannot see how they differ.

Same words, different meanings

Terms like “Christian”, “faith-based”, “biblically responsible”, and “values-aligned” are commonly used in the Christian financial industry. Each provider defines these terms in its own way or perhaps uses the terms without defining them at all.

The hidden differences between products tend to show up in three places. The first is in the terms used: what counts as “involvement” in an objectionable activity? Manufacturing the product? Distributing it? The second is thresholds: Is the approach a zero-tolerance approach? Is there a revenue threshold? The third is scope: Does the fund only screen out companies? Does it use its voice as an owner through proxy voting and engagement?

When these questions are not answered in ways easily accessible to investors, investors end up comparing marketing language rather than actual practice. As a result, firms doing hard, careful work may get no credit for it, since their promises look the same on paper as everyone else’s.

What a framework can do

The way to resolve this is by using a common framework, a set of shared definitions and disclosures that Christian investment products can be measured against.

Now, I acknowledge this may sound impossible. Christians hold sincere and long-standing differences on a range of questions. That is why we have Catholics and Baptists and Methodists and Anglicans. Because of this, it is worth being clear what a framework can do.

Think of a tape measure. It does not tell a carpenter what to build or an architect what to design. It does not choose between a porch and a deck, a shed or a barn. What it does ensure is that everyone involved in the job understands what “eight feet” means. Without that agreement, nothing gets built because no two people are working to the same scale. (Those readers who live in much older homes painfully understand what I mean here.)

A framework for Christian investing works the same way. It does not impose a single theology or rank one tradition over another. But it does make sure that when a product says it “excludes” something, everyone knows what “excludes” means and what was measured to support the claim.

Lessons from the secular side

This is not a new problem, nor is it unique to Christian investors. Secular sustainable investing faced it over a decade ago. The ESG movement created dozens of ratings, scores, and labels, with little ability to compare one against another.

The root of the challenge was very similar and anchored in what can be described as “doctrinal differences” among different groups. Over two decades ago, I co-led a major rating firm and designed the methodology for data collection and ratings. I was there in the muck, making up definitions, thresholds, and the scope of everything from what constituted involvement in alcohol or abortifacients, to how you managed the revenue derived from these activities. The resulting framework differed from other frameworks in the market, and we viewed that as a competitive edge. The truth is that it just made it harder for investors to understand what they owned and easier for asset managers to convince them they were fully aligned.

But such efforts did get something important right over time. Shared definitions eventually made real comparison possible on most things. They also showed how frameworks can become overly complex or be pulled down to the lowest common denominator, addressing only what is easiest to measure.

Three aspects of a good framework

A useful framework for Christian investing products needs to settle three things:

  • Terms: what do we mean by terms such as ownership, involvement, revenue, and alignment? If two or more providers use the same term, it should mean the same thing.
  • Thresholds: where is the line drawn? A fund may set it anywhere it believes faithfulness requires, but it should plainly state where that line is.
  • Disclosure: what must a provider tell participating investors about its screens, its voting records, and its exceptions? A promise that cannot be checked is not much of a promise.

A common framework protects distinct approaches and allows room for conviction. A Catholic fund and an evangelical fund may reasonably differ on issues. A useful framework allows these funds to differ openly, with each fund using language in a way so investors can see these differences and choose accordingly.

The Christian financial industry is still building a robust, fully diversified portfolio for all segments of Christian investing. Today, this industry has solutions that are marketed and promoted using non-standardized terminology. Each carpenter can use their thumb to measure an inch and need not explain if they are working in yards or meters.

However, a useful framework for Christian investors will help ensure transparency in what is being sold to the faithful and a clear understanding of the similarities and differences among strategies being offered.

Get updates

Subscribe to get the latest in educational insights and updates on the work of the CIC.

Get in touch

Send us a message and a member of the team will reply.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Download

Thank you for your interest in our work. Sign up for updates below to get access to this resource.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Determines which updates you receive.